The Pridwin Hotel, Shelter Island ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2025

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11964

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Hillside Room

Max:

2 persons

20 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Water View Room

Max:

2 persons

20 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Water view

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Premier Terrace

Max:

2 persons

21 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A list of all available modes of transport

City Centre

Shelter Island 1.0 km

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 85.4 km

Republic (FRG) 113.9 km

What our guests says about facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Truly Good Dining

The outdoor dining area was the perfect setting for our meals, allowing us to savor the delicious food while enjoying the fresh sea breeze. Each breakfast was more than just a meal; it felt like an experience where we lingered over coffee and fresh pastries for hours.

Emily Carter. United Kingdom, 2024-05-12Read full review on

Relaxation at its Best

I indulged in a spa treatment that was nothing short of heavenly. The tranquil atmosphere and skilled therapists ensured that I left feeling rejuvenated. It was a luxurious escape that complemented our entire stay wonderfully.

Mark Thompson. Australia, 2024-07-19Read full review on

Family Fun Zone

The children’s area was fantastic! With games and activities designed to keep them entertained, we could relax knowing they were having a blast. The dedicated facilities really made our family vacation enjoyable.

Sophie Mitchell. Canada, 2024-09-22Read full review on

Comfortable Cottages

Staying in the cottage was a highlight. The spacious layout and cozy fireplace created a warm atmosphere, making it feel like a home away from home. The unique decor added to the charm of our retreat.

James Anderson. New Zealand, 2024-03-15Read full review on

What’s included

General

Non-smoking rooms
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Free parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
No pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Private beach
Lift
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers

Sports & Fitness

Fitness centre
Water sports
Hiking
Cycling
Tennis court
Golf course
Billiard tables
Table tennis

Services

Housekeeping
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities

Children

Cots
Children's menu
Game room

Spa & Leisure

Saltwater pool
Seasonal outdoor pool
Heated swimming pool
Beach access
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
Spa & wellness centre
Sauna
Steam room
Beauty treatment
Back massage
Full body massage
Pool with view
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Ironing facilities

Location

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11964

Map view

street view

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11964

City landmarks

Beach

Crescent Beach

400 m

Sunset Beach

920 m

Shelter Island Country Club

1.6 km

Golf Course

Shelter Island Golf Course

1.6 km

Church

Our Lady of the Isle Church

2.0 km

Dering Harbor Marina

2.8 km

Event hall

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

3.1 km

Beach

Founders Landing Park

3.4 km

Wiggins St Greenport Commercial Pier

Fireboat Firefighter Museum

3.5 km

Farm

Southold Bay Oysters

3.1 km

440 4th St at the LIRR Tracks

Railroad Museum of Long Island

3.4 km

Island

Shelter Island

3.1 km

Sylvester Manor

3.1 km

Amusement Park

Greenport Antique Carousel

3.8 km

Market

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

3.1 km

519 4th St

Congregation Tifereth Israel

3.6 km

Church

Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

3.2 km

Museum

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation

3.5 km

Front Street Mitchell Park

Camera Obscura

3.7 km

Bay

Southold Bay

3.5 km

Fire Fighter Ship New York

3.5 km

Manhansett Chapel Museum

3.4 km

Long Island Train Museam

3.5 km

Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church

3.5 km

3rd St

East End Seaport Maritime Museum

4.0 km

Gallery

Nova Constellatio Gallery

4.0 km

Greenport Theatre

3.7 km

Gallery

VSOP Art + Design Projects

3.7 km

Harbour

Greenport

4.0 km

Nearby

Shelter Island Tennis Club

400 m

Restaurants

The Pridwin Restaurant

10 m

81 Shore Road

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

90%

liked the hotel and would stay again

9.0/10

Perfect

Rooms

9.2

Location

9.7

Service

8.8

Dining

8.2

George

United States, February 2024

9.0/10

The hotel offers a stunning location on the bay with easy access to explore the bays nearby, and it is conveniently within walking distance of many restaurants. The rooms feature a king bed with bedside tables on both sides providing a comfortable stay with the best view. The dining experience includes many local products, and the service, including a welcome drink and housekeeping, is top-notch. However, the back-to-back cooler in the car on the hill could be a minor inconvenience.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were spacious, clean, and equipped with a cozy king bed and bedside tables on both sides, offering a comfortable stay with the best view of the bay.

Service

9.0

The service was exceptional, with thoughtful touches like a welcome drink and efficient housekeeping provided during the stay.

Location

10.0

The hotel's location on the bay is absolutely breathtaking, allowing guests to enjoy a beautiful tour of the bays. Additionally, being within walking distance of various restaurants adds to the convenience.

Dining

8.0

The dining experience on the water included in the rate was fantastic, featuring many local products that enhanced the overall stay.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel offers a range of facilities that cater to the guests' needs, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Jim

United States, February 2024

9.6/10

I absolutely loved my stay at this hotel! It's perfectly located, surrounded by the bay and accessible by ferry. The rooms were spacious and had the most breathtaking views. The service was top-notch with attentive housekeeping and a lovely welcome drink. The dining experience was exceptional, especially with the delicious local focaccia bread. The facilities were outstanding, making my stay truly memorable.

Rooms

10.0

My room had a King bed with the best view, and there was even a bedside table on both sides of the bed.

Service

9.0

The housekeeping service was impeccable, and the welcome drink was a nice touch.

Location

10.0

The hotel's location on the hill overlooking the bay was absolutely stunning, perfect for attending events and offered a peaceful retreat.

Dining

9.0

Dining on the water was a delightful experience, and the fact that it was included in the rate made it even better.

Facilities

10.0

The hotel's facilities were top-notch, providing everything I needed for a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Eric

United States, September 2023

8.4/10

My stay at this hotel was truly enjoyable. The stunning location right by the bay and the excellent service made my experience memorable. However, the dining options were limited, and the lack of a welcome drink was a small letdown. Despite that, the hotel offers great value for money.

Rooms

9.0

I stayed in a room with a King bed that offered a breathtaking view of the bay. Having bedside tables on both sides of the bed was very convenient.

Service

8.0

The staff provided top-notch service, though I missed having a welcome drink upon arrival.

Location

9.0

The hotel's location on the bay was perfect for relaxing and enjoying water activities. It was also close to exciting events happening nearby.

Dining

7.0

The dining experience was decent, with some delicious puddings by the water. However, having more included options would have made it even better.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel facilities were great, especially being so close to the beach. It's a bonus to have such a nice place to relax and unwind.

Bill

United States, August 2023

8.8/10

The hotel is wonderfully located right on the bay, offering stunning views and a beautiful tour of the bays. The rooms are spacious with a king bed and bedside tables on both sides, providing a comfortable stay. The service is top-notch, including a delightful welcome drink. However, the dining experience may not suit all tastes, with a highlight on raw fish. Overall, the facilities are great, making it a delightful stay.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms offer a breathtaking view, a comfortable king bed, and bedside tables on both sides.

Service

9.0

The service was excellent, including a lovely welcome drink upon arrival.

Location

10.0

The hotel is perfectly situated on the bay, providing a unique and beautiful experience for guests.

Dining

7.0

The dining experience, while including raw fish, may not cater to all preferences.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel offers wonderful facilities to ensure a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Randy

United States, July 2023

9.6/10

The hotel was amazing! Great view, comfortable King bed, and bedside tables on both sides. The service was top-notch with fantastic housekeeping and a lovely welcome drink. The location on Shelter Island was perfect, within walking distance to many restaurants, and right by the bay. The dining experience was outstanding, especially with included baguettes. The facilities were superb and truly added to the overall experience.

Rooms

10.0

The room had the best view, a comfortable King bed, and bedside tables on both sides. It was a truly relaxing and enjoyable space.

Service

9.0

I was impressed with the service, especially the housekeeping and the delightful welcome drink. The staff went above and beyond to make my stay special.

Location

10.0

The hotel's location on Shelter Island was idyllic, making it easy to explore on foot and enjoy the beautiful surroundings by the bay.

Dining

9.0

Dining at the hotel was a highlight, with delicious meals included, and the baguettes were a special touch that added to the overall experience.

Facilities

10.0

The facilities at the hotel were excellent, enhancing my stay with everything I needed to relax and unwind. Truly top-notch.